Cognitive Ability Testing in Cybersecurity Hiring: Validity and Adverse Impact Considerations
APA Citation
Franklin, D. & Mendez, R. (2023). Cognitive Ability Testing in Cybersecurity Hiring: Validity and Adverse Impact Considerations. *Journal of Applied Psychology*. https://doi.org/10.1037/apl0001078
View original paper →What Did This Cybersecurity Research Find?
This cybersecurity hiring assessment study evaluated the predictive validity of cognitive ability tests for security role performance across 2,200 candidates. Cybersecurity roles requiring complex analytical reasoning (threat intelligence, malware analysis) showed the strongest validity for general cognitive ability tests, but the researchers also documented significant adverse impact concerns.
Key Findings
- 1Cognitive ability tests predicted performance for analytical security roles (validity = 0.41)
- 2Validity was lower for compliance and policy roles (validity = 0.19)
- 3Combining cognitive tests with structured interviews produced the highest overall validity (0.52)
- 4Adverse impact ratios were problematic when cognitive tests were the sole screening tool
- 5Work sample tests showed comparable validity with less adverse impact for entry-level roles
How Does This Apply to Cybersecurity Careers?
Organizations can select assessment tools that predict performance while minimizing unfair barriers. Candidates can understand what cognitive ability tests measure and why employers use them.
Who Should Read This?
Frequently Asked Questions
What did this cybersecurity research find?
This cybersecurity hiring assessment study evaluated the predictive validity of cognitive ability tests for security role performance across 2,200 candidates. Cybersecurity roles requiring complex analytical reasoning (threat intelligence, malware analysis) showed the strongest validity for general cognitive ability tests, but the researchers also documented significant adverse impact concerns.
How is this research relevant to cybersecurity careers?
Organizations can select assessment tools that predict performance while minimizing unfair barriers. Candidates can understand what cognitive ability tests measure and why employers use them.
Where was this cybersecurity research published?
This study was published in Journal of Applied Psychology in 2023. The DOI is 10.1037/apl0001078. Access the original paper through the publisher link above.
Explore Related Cybersecurity Resources
Get cybersecurity career insights delivered weekly
Join cybersecurity professionals receiving weekly intelligence on threats, job market trends, salary data, and career growth strategies.
Get Cybersecurity Career Intelligence
Weekly insights on threats, job trends, and career growth.
Unsubscribe anytime. More options